Reviewed by Liam M (age 8) and Jimmy W. (age 9)
I'm Jimmy, and I liked the book Because of WinnDixie because it's a story about friendship between a girl and a dog. An amazing dog that helps Opal get closer to her dad, remember her mom, and make lots of new friends. My favorite part of the story was when WinnDixie didn't kill the mouse that was at the church. He was so sweet and careful with the mouse while it was in his mouth. While reading this book, I made a strong connection with WinnDixie because I wouldn't want to hurt a mouse either if I caught one. I would let if go and be free too. I think most people will like this book. It has lots of twists, like when WinnDixie gets lost. I'm not telling you what happens, but if you like dogs and animals I bet you will like this book. You also might find this book interesting because it has lots of adventures.
I'm Liam, and I like the book Because of WinnDixie because it tells a lot about feelings. My favorite part was when Opal and WinnDixie met for the first time in the grocery store. Since that was the first time they had ever met, it would be a touching part. I made a strong connection with Otis because I am really shy like Otis is, but really only when I get in trouble. I also relate to Otis because I love to play the recorder in music like Otis likes to play his guitar.
We would recommend this book to Mrs. Schimmelpfennig, our teacher, because she loves animals, and she wouldn't just leave an animal on the street. We would also recommend this book to anyone who is eight years or older because they will be old enough to understand the feelings and all the big words that goes with those feelings. How important it is not to give up on something that you really really love.