Reviewed by Brynn M. (age 10)
When she is returning from her first trip ashore in America, a child loses her doll. Kit jumps into the water and gets it for her. Everyone is shocked and horrified. Kit asks the little girlís name and she says it is Prudence. Kit and Prudence become friends, even though Prudenceís mother doesnít like Kit. Kit also becomes friends with another traveler on the ship, John Holbrook.
When Kit gets to her auntís house in Wethersfield she has to do a lot of menial labor, but she also gets two cousins to talk to. Their names are Judith and Mercy. Mercy has a disability and her legs do not work, but she is kind. Judith is pretty and vain. One day, Judith and Kit were working out in the fields, and Kit sees a house out by the pond. Kit asks whoís house it is and Judith tells her the witch Hannah Tupper lives there. Kit wants to visit, but Judith tells her not to.
For a while Kit helps Mercy with the Dame school, a school for young children, but she gets fired for doing plays with the students. She is very upset and goes to the meadow. Hannah is there. Hannah lets Kit into her house and gives her food. They talk and Kit says she will come back. Over time Kit and Hannah become friends. Kitís friend Prudence (the girl from The Dolphin) begins to visit Kit and Hannah too.
Kitís family does not want her to visit Hannah. Her Uncle Matthew forbids her to go back. People are suspicious of Hannah because she is different. She is a Quaker in a Puritan town. Like Kit, she doesnít fit in. When a mysterious illness strikes the townspeople start talking about witchcraft, and Kit and Hannah are in danger. Read the book to find out what happens.
I liked this book because it was very interesting. There were some very unique things that happen with marriage and drama. This book is not like any other book I have ever read. This book is unique because it is in a different time period. There were a few characters I did not like, like Judith. I think Judith is rude and annoying. I like Mercy. She is really, really nice to everyone. When Kit is bad at doing her share of chores, Mercy is still very nice to her. Judith is kind of mean to Kit when she is bad at things.
I think that people ages 9 and up should read this book. I think they would like it because anyone younger would not understand the wording. I think readers who like big plot twists would like this book.